I know, this really gets to be splitting hairs about genre definitions. I don’t mind calling Cowboys & Aliens a Weird West movie because it takes place in the Wild West and then goes full-blown scifi. Something about upending a normal Western setting with scifi seems to work for me.

Yet creating James Bond-esque gadgets using technology that technically existed in the era (steam-power, magnets) doesn’t feel as scifi to me because while the devices are new to the residents, this isn’t “sufficiently advanced technology indistinguishable from magic”. Besides, if we consider James Bond-esque gadgets to be scifi, does that mean the James Bond series itself is scifi? I would’ve said no, but I can see your argument for it.

In the end, it doesn’t really matter. I just thought it’d be fun to discuss where we define the boundaries of this genre.