A company contracted by the government to assess technologies for verifying the ages of online users says it can be done privately, robustly and effectively.
The problem at the moment is that the technology does not aid parents in this.
Personally, I would like to see the existence of this sort of age-gating API be mandatory, and set some government guidelines, but leave it up to parents whether or not they wish to use it. Because right now, unless they are hovering over the shoulder of their children every moment they’re on a computer, there’s literally nothing they can do with available technology to prevent children accessing age-inappropriate material. So a law that can help them out without forcing their hand would be great.
I don’t think you’ll find anyone in the fediverse willing to defend face-based age-verification systems. It’s a complete farce to pretend it’s ever going to be viable, even if you completely ignore all the obvious privacy issues and how easily-bypassed it is. People’s faces just have far too weak a correlation with their age to get the kind of bright line result a law like this needs.
Uploading ID is a better option. Still bad because it kills all anonymity/pseudonimity and introduces enormous privacy risks. And is still not difficult to bypass. But if options for age verification were political parties, this would be the LNP, to facial-aging-AI’s One Nation.
The problem at the moment is that the technology does not aid parents in this.
Personally, I would like to see the existence of this sort of age-gating API be mandatory, and set some government guidelines, but leave it up to parents whether or not they wish to use it. Because right now, unless they are hovering over the shoulder of their children every moment they’re on a computer, there’s literally nothing they can do with available technology to prevent children accessing age-inappropriate material. So a law that can help them out without forcing their hand would be great.
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
Well said
I don’t think you’ll find anyone in the fediverse willing to defend face-based age-verification systems. It’s a complete farce to pretend it’s ever going to be viable, even if you completely ignore all the obvious privacy issues and how easily-bypassed it is. People’s faces just have far too weak a correlation with their age to get the kind of bright line result a law like this needs.
Uploading ID is a better option. Still bad because it kills all anonymity/pseudonimity and introduces enormous privacy risks. And is still not difficult to bypass. But if options for age verification were political parties, this would be the LNP, to facial-aging-AI’s One Nation.